Old brick is appealing because its surface records something of its first life. Differences in colour, small chips and traces of mortar can give a wall a texture that new materials rarely imitate convincingly. But appearance alone does not tell us where a brick can be used again.
Read the batch, not one sample
A single attractive brick says little about a whole delivery. Look at variations in size and condition across the batch. Ask the supplier where it came from, how it was cleaned and whether performance information is available for the intended use.
External exposure, frost and moisture place different demands on masonry than a sheltered internal surface. A local specialist should confirm suitability and the mortar approach. This is especially important when old and new materials meet.
Let variation be deliberate
A small sample panel makes choices easier to see. Joint width, mortar colour and the distribution of darker pieces can change the character of the wall as much as the bricks themselves. Photograph the panel in both sun and shade before making a decision.
Account for the practical work
Sorting, storage, transport and wastage belong in the conversation from the beginning. Reuse is most convincing when those details are understood, rather than hidden behind a photograph of a beautiful surface. Sometimes preserving an existing wall in place is the most interesting option of all.
See the material notebook for questions to ask about timber and plaster as well.